How to Identify Struggling Students
Before the First Report Card

By the time a student receives a failing grade on the first report card, a school may already have weeks of evidence that something is going wrong.

The missed classes were there. The late arrivals were there. Assignments began piling up. A teacher noticed that the student who participated during the first week had stopped raising their hand.

The problem is rarely a lack of data.

The problem is whether schools recognize those signals early enough, and whether they know what to do once they see them.

That is the purpose of early warning systems for students. A strong early-warning approach helps educators identify patterns before they become outcomes, investigate what is causing them, and connect students with the right support before the first marking period becomes a postmortem.

There is also a human reason to move quickly.

A student’s first report card can begin shaping how they see themselves as a learner.

Years ago, I heard a story about a teacher who gave every student a 100 at the beginning of a class. Instead of starting from zero and asking students to prove themselves, every student began with something worth protecting.

Whether or not we use that exact practice, the principle matters.

Labels are difficult to overcome.

When a child receives an early report card filled with failing grades, the danger is not simply the grades themselves. The student may begin thinking, I’m bad at math. I’m not a good student. School isn’t for me.

School leaders should be trying to interrupt that story before it gets written.

What Should an Early Warning System Monitor?

The research on student early-warning systems has historically centered on three categories often called the ABCs: attendance, behavior, and course performance. These indicators are useful precisely because they are observable, routinely collected by schools, and connected to later academic outcomes.

For school leaders, that can translate into monitoring signals such as:

  • classroom attendance and repeated absences
  • lateness and changes in punctuality
  • missing or incomplete assignments
  • declining course grades
  • behavior or disciplinary patterns
  • teacher observations about engagement, relationships, or sudden changes

 

But I would not treat every signal equally.

I would start with attendance and timeliness.

Start With the Simplest Question: Is the Student There?

Everything else becomes harder when a student is not in the classroom.

If students are repeatedly missing class or arriving late, they are losing instructional time before anyone has even looked at a gradebook. They may miss the lesson that makes tomorrow’s assignment understandable. Then they do not complete the assignment. Then their grade declines. Then they become frustrated. Then they may become even less interested in attending.

One early signal can quickly become a domino effect.

Research supports treating attendance as a meaningful early-warning indicator. The Institute of Education Sciences notes that early-warning systems can use attendance information to identify students who are chronically absent or at risk of becoming chronically absent and then connect those students with appropriate supports.

A randomized study of 73 high schools involving more than 37,000 ninth- and tenth-grade students also found that schools implementing an Early Warning Intervention and Monitoring System had lower rates of chronic absence, 10% compared with 14% in control schools, and lower rates of failing one or more courses, 21% compared with 26%.

Leaders should not wait, however, until a student officially reaches the definition of chronic absenteeism.

Recent research examining absenteeism as an early-warning measure found that thresholds associated with academic risk can fall below the commonly used benchmark of missing 10% of school days.

That means schools need to look for patterns, not simply thresholds.

A student who has already missed four of the first 20 instructional days is telling you something.

The next question is: What?

A Flag Is the Beginning of the Conversation, Not the Diagnosis

An early-warning dashboard can tell a school that a student has missed class.

It cannot automatically tell you why.

Maybe the student dislikes the class.

Maybe they are struggling academically and avoiding an environment where they feel unsuccessful.

Maybe there is a conflict with the teacher or another student.

Maybe transportation is unreliable.

Maybe something is happening at home.

Maybe they are physically in school every day but routinely arriving late to one particular class.

Those circumstances call for very different responses.

This is where teacher observation becomes particularly valuable. The quantitative data should tell a team where to look. Teachers, counselors, students, and families can help determine what is happening.

That distinction matters because the strongest early-warning system is not necessarily the one generating the largest number of alerts.

It is the one helping adults ask better questions sooner.

Look at the Signals Together

Attendance may be where I would start, but it should not be where the analysis ends.

If a student has suddenly begun missing Algebra, look at the rest of the picture:

  • Is the student attending other classes?
  • Have assignments stopped coming in?
  • Did grades decline before attendance did?
  • Has there been a behavior change?
  • What is the teacher observing?
  • What does the student say?

 

Patterns across multiple indicators can help educators distinguish between an isolated incident and a trajectory that requires intervention.

This is consistent with the design of many established early-warning systems. Research has repeatedly used attendance, behavior, and course performance together because these indicators frequently capture different dimensions of student disengagement.

School leaders should also avoid assuming that a universal cutoff will perfectly identify risk in every school. Guidance from the Regional Educational Laboratory West recommends using local historical data because the predictive power of indicators and appropriate thresholds can differ across contexts.

 

In other words, learn from your own students.

  • Which attendance patterns preceded course failure last year?
  • How many missing assignments typically appeared before a student’s grade became difficult to recover?
  • Were certain transition grades particularly vulnerable?
  • Which students were eventually identified as struggling but could have been identified several weeks earlier?

 

Those questions turn an early-warning system from a generic framework into a school-specific tool.

Don't Build Another List of Students

This is where many early-warning efforts break down.

Schools generate a list.

The list gets discussed.

Another spreadsheet gets created.

And students keep struggling.

Data are useful only when they change adult behavior.

A national study of public high schools found that even among schools collecting early-warning information, collecting an indicator did not guarantee that it would trigger an intervention. Among schools measuring truancy or chronic absenteeism, for example, not all had established a threshold that prompted action.

That distinction is critical.

Your system should answer two questions: Who needs attention?

And then: What happens next?

If the second answer is unclear, you do not yet have an early-warning system. You have a reporting system.

Use a Premortem to Decide What "Next" Means

Schools can also make mistakes in the opposite direction.

Sometimes educators fail to take an early signal seriously enough.

Other times, because we care deeply about students and feel the urgency of the situation, we overreact.

Neither is helpful.

My rule is: The context should drive the consequence.

The challenge is that context can be difficult to evaluate objectively when everyone is already emotionally invested in a situation.

That is why school leaders should do some of this thinking before the problems happen.

One useful exercise is a premortem.

Before the school year, or before the first marking period gets too far underway, bring the leadership, attendance, counseling, MTSS, or student-support team together and imagine that the first marking period went terribly.

Ask:

  • What went wrong?
  • Which patterns did we miss?
  • Which warning signs appeared first?
  • Which students did we notice too late?
  • What did adults do, or fail to do, after those signals appeared?

 

Then work backward.

Build an Intervention Ladder Before You Need It

Use patterns from prior years to establish common responses for situations you are likely to encounter again.

For example:

First signal: A student has been late to the same class several times.

Response: Teacher checks in privately with the student and documents what they learn.

Pattern continues: Attendance or student-support staff review the student’s schedule and attendance across classes.

Academic effects appear: Teacher, advisor, counselor, or tutor creates a short recovery plan for missing work or misunderstood content.

Pattern persists or additional concerns emerge: Family outreach and a coordinated intervention plan.

Significant barriers are identified: Escalate to the appropriate school-based supports or external services.

This is not about automating discipline.

It is about pre-calibrating support.

There should always be professional judgment. But adults should not have to invent the school’s response from scratch every time a student struggles.

Research on early-warning interventions similarly emphasizes identifying students, assigning interventions, and then monitoring whether students respond to those interventions, not simply flagging risk once.

Monitor Whether the Intervention Worked

The final component is the one most likely to be forgotten.

After the intervention, look again.

  • Did attendance improve?
  • Is the student arriving on time?
  • Are assignments being completed?
  • Has the teacher noticed a change?
  • Did the student say the underlying problem was actually addressed?

 

If nothing changed, that is information too.

It may mean the diagnosis was wrong.

It may mean the intervention was too small.

It may mean a different adult needs to build the relationship.

Or it may mean there is a deeper barrier that has not yet been identified.

Early-warning systems should therefore operate as a cycle Identify. Investigate. Intervene. Monitor. Adjust.

Then repeat.

Final Thoughts: The Goal Is Not to Predict Failure. It Is to Prevent It.

There is an important philosophical difference between identifying a student who is “at risk” and deciding that the student is destined to fail.

The first creates an opportunity.

The second creates a label.

That is why leaders should be careful about the language surrounding early-warning systems. Students are not data points, and a red flag on a dashboard should never become an identity.

The purpose of the system is to give adults enough information, and enough time, to act while the trajectory can still be changed.

Do not wait for a report card to confirm what attendance, missing work, classroom behavior, and teachers may have been telling you for weeks.

Watch for the signal.

Understand the context.

Match the response to the need.

And intervene early enough that the student’s first marking period tells a story of recovery rather than failure.

Because the best early-warning system is not the one that predicts which students will fail.

It is the one that helps make the prediction wrong.

Looking for a better way to catch student risk early and respond with the right support? PRACTICE helps schools combine Gradebook visibility with in-person and on-demand tutoring, so leaders can identify patterns sooner, target academic support, and monitor whether interventions are helping.

Real Impact, Real Results: Explore Our Case Studies